Subscribe to our newsletters

Sign up to our morning and evening newsletters for Garowe's well curated list of our daily highlights.

Garowe Online
  • Home
  • Somalia
  • World
    • Africa
  • National Security
  • Environment
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Cartoons
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Register
Garowe Online
  • Home
  • Somalia
  • World
    • Africa
  • National Security
  • Environment
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Cartoons
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
Garowe Online
No Result
View All Result

Al-Shabab Fears Somalia's Military Court, Judge Says

Author
01/15/2022
in Somalia
Reading Time: 4 mins read
Al-Shabab Fears Somalia's Military Court

But the chairman said he remains committed to his work

0
SHARES
3
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

You might also like

A keen look at Somalia’s new cabinet

ISIS turns to Ethiopia for recruitment of new fighters

How women are contributing to Al-Shabaab insurgency in Somalia





Al-Shabab Fears Somalia's Military Court, Judge Says

Al-Shabab Fears Somalia's Military Court, Judge Says

Al-Shabab militants relentlessly carry out attacks in Somalia, such as Wednesday's suicide car bombing in Mogadishu that killed at least 10 people. The group claimed responsibility for the assault on a security caravan.

When the group is not staging direct attacks, it uses intimidation to collect “zakat,” or taxes, and fees from Somali businesses to finance its operations.

The violent group, which has been trying to impose an extreme version of Islam in Somalia since 2007, inspires terror. But its own members fear judgment in Somalia's military courtrooms, says a Somali military judge, who has prosecuted hundreds of such cases.

Hassan Ali Nur Shute, chairman of the Somali National Armed Forces military court, told VOA Somali that he interviewed an al-Shabab suspect who related that “members are told to take their lives when carrying out attacks” rather than stand trial in a military court.

“They know about the court,” Shute said of al-Shabab militants. “They tell each other that they will face justice.”

As chairman, Shute supervises 11 other military judges. Since 2017, they collectively have tried 659 alleged militants on charges of murder, terrorism, or both, Shute said. Of those, 455 – mostly al-Shabab militants, and a few affiliated with the Islamic State group – have been convicted.

Seventeen have been executed, including Hassan Aden Isak, who coordinated a double truck bombing in Mogadishu on Oct. 14, 2017, that killed 587 people. Isak was executed exactly a year later.

Ten other al-Shabab fighters remain on death row.

Somalia's military justice system requires a three-judge panel for any trial, whether for alleged militants or defendants from the armed forces. The overwhelming majority of cases are heard in Mogadishu, but military judges also travel to various Somali regions and towns. The hearings are public – sometimes even televised – with attorneys for the prosecution and defense. Decisions involving the death penalty must be unanimous, and Shute must approve each one.

Concerns about rights

But the system faces opposition, mainly from rights organizations and others that contend cases involving defendants with suspected terrorist ties should be transferred to civilian courts.

“The military court does not have legal jurisdiction over al-Shabab-related cases,” said Laetitia Bader, Horn of Africa director for Human Rights Watch (HRW).

She said the system operates under an outdated 2011 presidential decree that declared a state of emergency in parts of Mogadishu vacated by al-Shabab.

“Although the state of emergency expired after three months, the military court has continued to try a range of defendants beyond those envisioned under the Military Code of Criminal Procedure,” HRW wrote in a 2014 report challenging what it called the court's “absolute power.”

Ali Halane, a Somali defense lawyer based in Mogadishu, also contends that military courts should not try defendants with alleged ties to al-Shabab or any other terrorist organization. He said the military justice system, set up in 1964, limits the court's jurisdiction to defendants who are members of the armed forces.

“These are civilians, citizens,” Halane said of alleged al-Shabab defendants. “They have a right to be tried by courts trying civilians. And if they are fighting against the army, they should have access to a fair trial. They should find a neutral body.”

Bader also worries that the military courts do not respect due process, one of the issues HRW raised in its 2014 report. She questioned the reliability of interrogations conducted while a suspect is in the custody of intelligence services. She fears detainees have limited access to legal counsel, noting that from 2011 to 2014 the court relied solely on confessions.

“Confessions are taken from individuals when they were held in detention facilities” or without “access to legal counsel, to their relatives, are particularly concerning,” said Bader, who also raised concern about the speed of trials.

Shute defended the military court system's practices, saying al-Shabab is treated as military because it's an armed organization engaged in a deadly war aimed at toppling Somalia's government. He said the very reason the court was established was to deliver “swift justice.”

Brigadier General Abdi Hassan Hussein, a former intelligence officer and former police commander of the Puntland region, also supports trying suspected al-Shabab defendants in the military court system. The official, also known as Abdi Yare, said some al-Shabab units are trained, organized, armed and uniformed like the military. They sometimes disguise themselves in military or police uniforms to undertake attacks.

Hussein said Somalia's Parliament should pass an anti-terrorism law to empower the military court.

Perilous profession

Shute, now 35, holds a master's degree in law. He joined the military court system in 2011 and was appointed to the bench the following year.

Trying terrorism cases inevitably has exposed him to personal threats and loss.

On Jan. 2, 2018, his father Nur Shute visited the judge's office, advising him to leave government service and study abroad. An hour after his father left, Shute received a phone call that his dad had been assassinated. Al-Shabab claimed responsibility for the killing.

Shute also has lost colleagues to al-Shabab killings: Deputy Attorney General Mohamed Abdirahman Mursal in March 2019, criminal investigator Hassan Dhere in April 2018, and military court prosecutor Abdullahi Hussein Mohamed in October 2016. On the day of Mohamed's death, an al-Shabab spokesman had threatened retaliation for executions ordered by the court.

So, Shute considers himself a marked man. Always under guard, he travels in bullet-proof vehicles – which helped him survive a roadside explosion while returning from a military base in Lower Shabelle on Sept. 25, 2019. He lives separate from his family, fearing that they could be vulnerable if al-Shabab came knocking at the door. He said even his relatives and friends avoid his company, worried they could be impacted.

But the chairman said he remains committed to his work, bolstered by public reaction. And the court's Facebook page shows considerable public support for trying al-Shabab members.

He said the military courts' efforts help Somalis feel more secure.

“Ordinary people … have seen that al-Shabab can be prosecuted,” Shute said. “They were not even mentioning al-Shabab's name out loud before. They used code words like 'Arsenal is playing today.'”

This report was developed from VOA Somali Service's “Investigative Dossier” program.

Copyright © GAROWONLINE All Rights Reserved


Tags: somalia

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

ShareTweet
Previous Post

Ethiopia lashes out at WHO chief for Tigray war remarks

Next Post

At least 108 civilians killed this month in Tigray airstrikes: UN

Recommended For You

A keen look at Somalia’s new cabinet

08/03/2022
A keen look at Somalia’s new cabinet

MOGADISHU, Somalia - Although the main point of focus was anchored in the appointment of Mukhtar Robow, the former Al-Shabaab deputy commander as the new minister for Endowment...

Read more

ISIS turns to Ethiopia for recruitment of new fighters

08/01/2022
ISIS turns to Ethiopia for recruitment of new fighters

NAIROBI, Kenya - Ethiopia could be the latest epicenter of recruitment of terrorists, it has emerged, following competing interests by rivals Al-Shabaab and IS-Somalia, who have been lately...

Read more

How women are contributing to Al-Shabaab insurgency in Somalia

07/28/2022
How women are contributing to Al-Shabaab insurgency in Somalia

MOGADISHU, Somalia - Although they are sometimes victims of war and other calamities, women could be the people, after all, playing integral roles in the war against the...

Read more

Inside Al-Shabaab’s rare attack near Ethiopia border

07/23/2022
Inside Al-Shabaab’s rare attack near Ethiopia border

MOGADISHU, Somalia - By Friday, authorities in the Somali region of Ethiopia confirmed that over 100 Al-Shabaab militants have been killed within Ethiopia following their strategic crossover to...

Read more

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related News

Nearly 40 Percent Of Tigrayans Face ‘Extreme Lack Of Food’: UN 

Nearly 40 Percent Of Tigrayans Face ‘Extreme Lack Of Food’: UN 

01/28/2022
US ambassador: Al-Shabaab is stronger than ever

US ambassador: Al-Shabaab is stronger than ever

03/15/2022
Somalia loses UN voting rights over unpaid dues

Somalia loses UN voting rights over unpaid dues

01/13/2022

Browse by Category

  • Africa
  • Business
  • Business
  • Cartoons
  • Editorial
  • Environment
  • National Security
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Somalia
  • World
Garowe Online

The independent news Web site GaroweOnline.com is the online sister publication of Radio Garowe, a community radio station based in Garowe, the State capital of Puntland, a self-governing region in northern Somalia.

CATEGORIES

  • Africa
  • Business
  • Business
  • Cartoons
  • Editorial
  • Environment
  • National Security
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Somalia
  • World

BROWSE BY TAG

Abdirahman Abdishakur Abiy Ahmed africa Africom Al-Shabaab Al shabaab alshabaab AMISOM ATMIS Biden Danab election elections Eritrea Ethiopia Fahad Yasiin farmajo featured federal Hassan Shiekh Journalist Kenya Madeira mogadishu NISA Oil Parliament Police Puntland roble Rooble Said Dani SNA somalia somaliland Tigray Turkey UAE Ukrain UN US USA Villa Somalia WFP world

Copyright © GAROWONLINE All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Somalia
  • World
    • Africa
  • National Security
  • Environment
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Cartoons
  • Sports

Copyright © GAROWONLINE All Rights Reserved

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In